The Predator Is Never Trans. It’s Your Uncle

The people shouting loudest about trans predators never have to answer for the mountain of cisgender men behind the actual crimes, and StillNotTrans exists to make them look at it.

In October 2009 I wrote about Jonathan Matheny, a CVS manager in Gainesville, Florida. He’d campaigned for the charter amendment to “keep men out of women’s restrooms.” Then a customer found a phone camera hidden under tissues in his store’s bathroom, and Matheny was charged with video voyeurism. My reaction at the time fit in four words: can you say projection?

Seventeen years later, I’m still saying it.

It’s about the hypocrisy

Nobody ever claimed Matheny was trans. That’s the point. The predators aren’t usually trans. The problem isn’t trans people. The problem, mostly, is CISGENDER MEN.

So much anger gets pointed at trans people as “perverts” and “paedophiles” and “deviants,” while the people who are the actual problem get a huge fucking miss.

The anti-trans crowd does the work of the patriarchy. They’ll talk about abolishing gender without explaining how that works. They’ll make allies into enemies. And all the while, they’ll center trans people instead of their dad, their husband, their coach, or their uncle. It’s fucking TIRESOME.

It isn’t only the activists. The general public does it too. People scapegoat trans people in public and talk about “keeping women and girls safe,” when trans women aren’t the problem.

Before it was a website

StillNotTrans started as a hashtag on Twitter. I was throwing #stillnottrans at the bathroom panic on Twitter back when I still lived in the States, and I wasn’t the only one. Monica Roberts used it a lot. She was a Black trans woman who really shaped the advocacy I did. In May 2016 she quote-tweeted a Houston story about three teens charged after a bathroom assault with one line: “#Stillnottrans Who are the predators endangering our kids again?”

Monica taught me to keep pushing, to be strategic while being passionate, and to not stop. She saw it all as a chess match: look ahead, see where the pieces land or might land.

I’ve owned the domain since the name became a thing. Now it’s a site that keeps the receipts.

A mirror, not a database

Statistics matter. I know a list of cases proves nothing on its own. I can make cis women look unsafe around young boys very easily. Hell, I can do it with posts from my own site. Take a look at the Teacher category. It’s been live less than a month and there’s already three stories.

Cis women must not teach boys, right?

Of course not. That’s the joke, and it’s the same logic anti-trans activists use on us every day. The site says it plainly on the About page:

When a trans person is accused of a crime, it makes headlines, and their gender becomes the story. When the accused is a cisgender pastor, teacher, coach or submarine commander, nobody asks what their gender has to do with it.

This site keeps the receipts. Every post is a real news story about someone who isn’t trans. Each one links to the original report and to an archived copy, so it can’t quietly disappear.

The point is simple: being trans doesn’t make someone dangerous, and being cis doesn’t make someone safe.

What the gender-critical crowd won’t do

Gender-critical feminists will tell you they agree that men are the problem. They just count trans women as men. I’d take their “criticism” seriously if it went further than calling transgender women men. If they could cite actual research showing trans women offend at the same rates as cisgender men. Or if they’d admit that trans people are far more often the victims than the perpetrators. Trans people are over four times more likely than cis people to be victims of violent crime.

Instead, they point at prison figures. Criminals in prison, who knew! A prison is the worst sample you could pick. Are we going to judge all cis women by the actions of cis women prisoners?

And the bathroom panic? Trans-inclusive bathroom protections have existed in parts of the US for decades, and the research shows they don’t change the number of crimes in restrooms or locker rooms.

I’m all for studying criminality in trans women, especially over time. Even if it shows we offend at the same rates as cis men. I don’t believe that’s the case, from my own experience. But like with trans women in sport, my issue isn’t winning the debate for my side. It’s looking for the truth. If a trans woman has an undeniable advantage in a sport, there should be something that evens it out. I’m looking for evidence and searching for facts, not my side winning.

Why it looks like a tabloid

The red masthead and the screaming headlines are on purpose. The tabloids spent a decade putting “transgender” in headline type, so I put “cisgender” in the same spot. The people who want to use trans people that way will keep doing it, so I’ll use their format right back.

The same goes for the churches. Most of them will blare about it when one trans person commits a crime, and stay silent about the piles of victims of pastors and priests alone. There are affirming churches, but they’re the minority.

I don’t need their doctrine. I know what Isaiah 56:4–5 says to the eunuchs who hold fast to the covenant: “Even unto them will I give in mine house and within my walls a place and a name better than of sons and of daughters.” I know the book of Esther puts eunuchs in charge of the king’s women. When I was about ten, my picture Bible had a painting of a eunuch, and they LOOKED femme. I stored it in my head as fact. Nobody debated it, because nobody debated trans people back then.

The mountain

What do I want a reader to take away? I want them to see the MOUNTAIN of cisgender people who are the problem.

I want the hypocrisy, the silence, the complicity in the trauma they ignore so they can focus on trans people, to be impossible to miss. I think anyone who thinks about it for five seconds will walk away seeing it.

I’ll shut StillNotTrans down when we aren’t scapegoated and used as punching bags by people who should know better.

Until then: can you say projection?